UNCONVENTIONAL
Twenty-Two Tales of Paranormal Gatherings Under the Guise of Conventions
Editors: Kate Kaynak and Trisha Wooldridge
Paperback: 320 pages
Publisher: Spencer Hill Press (January 15, 2012)
Disclosure: Obtained anonymously at BEA. No remuneration exchanged and all opinions herein are my own unless stated otherwise.
When I picked this up at BEA, I thought it was the perfect paranormal companion to this year's convention and election season. There are a lot of stories in the collection. I enjoyed several: Keshia Swan's Family Ties, Shadow Harper by Sherry Thompson, Myrtle by Melina Gunnett, Belief by Vikki Ciaffone, Escalation is Academic by Ira Nayman, and The Waltz by Lauren Marrero. I found a few stories tolerable and the rest did not appeal to me. Of the stories I liked, I think the best were Family Ties, Shadow Harper, which was the perfect blend of etheral and real for its length, and Myrtle.
The stories are proofed; I was not distracted by typos or grammatical errors. However, there is a difference between superficial editing and story editing. Many of the stories needed editing to be good short stories.
In an anthology, it seems to me there are two tasks for the editors: editing and curating. The most profound issue is the oblique entry into a story world. While common as a device in longer format fiction. In an anthology of short stories it wastes pages. In a few stories I was just unable to determine what was happening. In one a female character is given a name usually reserved for males. Since she is interacting with three boys I was unsure whether she was the named character. By the time I figured it out I was too dismayed to finish the story.
Another curating issue, or book design issue, are the subtitles that appear under each author's name with the author and the author's place of residence between the two. At first, I thought they were descriptions of the author: the first was Debut Author, another was Guest. Reading on though, I realized that was not the case. They were just unnecessary and confused me.
The biggest issue I had with the anthology was that it was too many stories with the same theme. In most instances it was about fan or fantasy conventions, like comic con, Twi-con or Dragon-con. There were a few different gatherings, like a cruise or academic conference. Most stories featured fan cons where someone wasn't just dressed-up like an alien or fantasy creature, they were one. If this were an anthology of slightly longer stories with this theme it wouldn't have become tedious, but I felt I was reading the same story over and over.
Anthologies are a tough call. After all, I liked six of the twenty two, found three or four simply unreadable and the rest were meh to bleh! If I had a star rating system I guess that would place it smack-dab in the center at two-and-a-half.
Purchase Links:
A West Coast Fave:

Amazon:
OR Buy UNCONVENTIONAL at BORDERS via my affiliate link

Twenty-Two Tales of Paranormal Gatherings Under the Guise of Conventions
Editors: Kate Kaynak and Trisha Wooldridge
Paperback: 320 pages
Publisher: Spencer Hill Press (January 15, 2012)
Disclosure: Obtained anonymously at BEA. No remuneration exchanged and all opinions herein are my own unless stated otherwise.
![]() |
| spencerhillpress.com |
BLURB:
It's about to get weird... okay, weirder in here.
Alien ascensions in hotel ballrooms.
Mermaids on cruise ships.
Werewolves in dog shows.
Steampunk fairy time travelers.
A teenage superhero hitching a ride with a supervillain.
Comic books that absorb their readers.
Magical filk... and much more.
With stories by: LJ Berger, Vikki Ciaffone, Daniel Cohen, Gordon Dupuis, Anthony G. Francis, Jr., Justine Graykin, Randy O. Green, Melina Gunnett, Kate Kaynak, Danielle M. LeFevre, Kimberley Long-Ewing, Lauren Marrero, Will Morton, LS Murphy, Ira Nayman, KT Pinto, Jennifer Allis Provost, Patricia Puckett, Keshia Swaim, Sherry Thompson, Pamela van Hylckama Vlieg, and Trisha Wooldridge
spencerhillpress.com
When I picked this up at BEA, I thought it was the perfect paranormal companion to this year's convention and election season. There are a lot of stories in the collection. I enjoyed several: Keshia Swan's Family Ties, Shadow Harper by Sherry Thompson, Myrtle by Melina Gunnett, Belief by Vikki Ciaffone, Escalation is Academic by Ira Nayman, and The Waltz by Lauren Marrero. I found a few stories tolerable and the rest did not appeal to me. Of the stories I liked, I think the best were Family Ties, Shadow Harper, which was the perfect blend of etheral and real for its length, and Myrtle.
The stories are proofed; I was not distracted by typos or grammatical errors. However, there is a difference between superficial editing and story editing. Many of the stories needed editing to be good short stories.
In an anthology, it seems to me there are two tasks for the editors: editing and curating. The most profound issue is the oblique entry into a story world. While common as a device in longer format fiction. In an anthology of short stories it wastes pages. In a few stories I was just unable to determine what was happening. In one a female character is given a name usually reserved for males. Since she is interacting with three boys I was unsure whether she was the named character. By the time I figured it out I was too dismayed to finish the story.
Another curating issue, or book design issue, are the subtitles that appear under each author's name with the author and the author's place of residence between the two. At first, I thought they were descriptions of the author: the first was Debut Author, another was Guest. Reading on though, I realized that was not the case. They were just unnecessary and confused me.
The biggest issue I had with the anthology was that it was too many stories with the same theme. In most instances it was about fan or fantasy conventions, like comic con, Twi-con or Dragon-con. There were a few different gatherings, like a cruise or academic conference. Most stories featured fan cons where someone wasn't just dressed-up like an alien or fantasy creature, they were one. If this were an anthology of slightly longer stories with this theme it wouldn't have become tedious, but I felt I was reading the same story over and over.
Anthologies are a tough call. After all, I liked six of the twenty two, found three or four simply unreadable and the rest were meh to bleh! If I had a star rating system I guess that would place it smack-dab in the center at two-and-a-half.
Purchase Links:
A West Coast Fave:
Amazon:
OR Buy UNCONVENTIONAL at BORDERS via my affiliate link










Griffin—James's cousin and fellow pirate from 





